Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper sets out a tentative quantified analysis of long-term trends in the settlement history of the northern Oman peninsula from prehistoric times to the Late Islamic period, based on published archaeological evidence. Although the data set used is undeniably problematic, it is argued that despite the sheer quantity of available evidence, the database will have ironed out at least some of the specific and localized problems that exist, and will therefore give a broadly correct indication of general long-term trends. It is clear from both academic conversations and the published material that implicit and unsystematic reviews of precisely this data set are regularly used by many scholars in impressionistic and non-rigorous ways - especially as the basis for consensus opinions on trends in the relative density of activity and occupation in different periods. Therefore, the opportunity has been taken here to put such comparisons on a firmer footing and to make them more explicit and testable. The robustness of the data can - and should - then be debated. The stability of some of the longer-term trends suggests that this data could be acceptable in low-grade analyses such as those presented here. Nonetheless, caution must still be applied until the conclusions can be more rigorously tested.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies
PublisherArchaeopress
Pages133-144
Number of pages12
Volume41
ISBN (Print)9781905739400
Publication statusPublished - 2011
Event44th Meeting of the Seminar for Arabian Studies - London, United Kingdom
Duration: Jul 22 2010Jul 24 2010

Other

Other44th Meeting of the Seminar for Arabian Studies
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLondon
Period7/22/107/24/10

Fingerprint

settlement history
archaeological evidence
footing
occupation
trend
long-term trend
analysis
opinion
firm
material
comparison

Keywords

  • Database of sites
  • Northern Oman peninsula
  • Quantification problems
  • Quantified analysis
  • Settlement trends

Cite this

Al-Jahwari, N. S. (2011). Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula. In Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies (Vol. 41, pp. 133-144). Archaeopress.

Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula. / Al-Jahwari, Nasser Said.

Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies. Vol. 41 Archaeopress, 2011. p. 133-144.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Al-Jahwari, NS 2011, Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula. in Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies. vol. 41, Archaeopress, pp. 133-144, 44th Meeting of the Seminar for Arabian Studies, London, United Kingdom, 7/22/10.
Al-Jahwari NS. Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula. In Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies. Vol. 41. Archaeopress. 2011. p. 133-144
Al-Jahwari, Nasser Said. / Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula. Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies. Vol. 41 Archaeopress, 2011. pp. 133-144
@inproceedings{91671df17e8740e884e47b3ca2183879,
title = "Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula",
abstract = "This paper sets out a tentative quantified analysis of long-term trends in the settlement history of the northern Oman peninsula from prehistoric times to the Late Islamic period, based on published archaeological evidence. Although the data set used is undeniably problematic, it is argued that despite the sheer quantity of available evidence, the database will have ironed out at least some of the specific and localized problems that exist, and will therefore give a broadly correct indication of general long-term trends. It is clear from both academic conversations and the published material that implicit and unsystematic reviews of precisely this data set are regularly used by many scholars in impressionistic and non-rigorous ways - especially as the basis for consensus opinions on trends in the relative density of activity and occupation in different periods. Therefore, the opportunity has been taken here to put such comparisons on a firmer footing and to make them more explicit and testable. The robustness of the data can - and should - then be debated. The stability of some of the longer-term trends suggests that this data could be acceptable in low-grade analyses such as those presented here. Nonetheless, caution must still be applied until the conclusions can be more rigorously tested.",
keywords = "Database of sites, Northern Oman peninsula, Quantification problems, Quantified analysis, Settlement trends",
author = "Al-Jahwari, {Nasser Said}",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781905739400",
volume = "41",
pages = "133--144",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies",
publisher = "Archaeopress",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Quantified analysis of long-term settlement trends in the northern Oman peninsula

AU - Al-Jahwari, Nasser Said

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - This paper sets out a tentative quantified analysis of long-term trends in the settlement history of the northern Oman peninsula from prehistoric times to the Late Islamic period, based on published archaeological evidence. Although the data set used is undeniably problematic, it is argued that despite the sheer quantity of available evidence, the database will have ironed out at least some of the specific and localized problems that exist, and will therefore give a broadly correct indication of general long-term trends. It is clear from both academic conversations and the published material that implicit and unsystematic reviews of precisely this data set are regularly used by many scholars in impressionistic and non-rigorous ways - especially as the basis for consensus opinions on trends in the relative density of activity and occupation in different periods. Therefore, the opportunity has been taken here to put such comparisons on a firmer footing and to make them more explicit and testable. The robustness of the data can - and should - then be debated. The stability of some of the longer-term trends suggests that this data could be acceptable in low-grade analyses such as those presented here. Nonetheless, caution must still be applied until the conclusions can be more rigorously tested.

AB - This paper sets out a tentative quantified analysis of long-term trends in the settlement history of the northern Oman peninsula from prehistoric times to the Late Islamic period, based on published archaeological evidence. Although the data set used is undeniably problematic, it is argued that despite the sheer quantity of available evidence, the database will have ironed out at least some of the specific and localized problems that exist, and will therefore give a broadly correct indication of general long-term trends. It is clear from both academic conversations and the published material that implicit and unsystematic reviews of precisely this data set are regularly used by many scholars in impressionistic and non-rigorous ways - especially as the basis for consensus opinions on trends in the relative density of activity and occupation in different periods. Therefore, the opportunity has been taken here to put such comparisons on a firmer footing and to make them more explicit and testable. The robustness of the data can - and should - then be debated. The stability of some of the longer-term trends suggests that this data could be acceptable in low-grade analyses such as those presented here. Nonetheless, caution must still be applied until the conclusions can be more rigorously tested.

KW - Database of sites

KW - Northern Oman peninsula

KW - Quantification problems

KW - Quantified analysis

KW - Settlement trends

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84908894627&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84908894627&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:84908894627

SN - 9781905739400

VL - 41

SP - 133

EP - 144

BT - Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies

PB - Archaeopress

ER -