Culture and the distinctiveness motive

Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts

Maja Becker, Vivian L. Vignoles, Ellinor Owe, Rupert Brown, Peter B. Smith, Matt Easterbrook, Ginette Herman, Isabelle De Sauvage, David Bourguignon, Ana Torres, Leoncio Camino, Flávia Cristina Silveira Lemos, M. Cristina Ferreira, Silvia H. Koller, Roberto Gonzãlez, Diego Carrasco, Maria Paz Cadena, Siugmin Lay, Qian Wang, Michael Harris Bond & 20 others Elvia Vargas Trujillo, Paola Balanta, Aune Valk, Kassahun Habtamu Mekonnen, George Nizharadze, Marta Fülöp, Camillo Regalia, Claudia Manzi, Maria Brambilla, Charles Harb, Said Aldhafri, Mariana Martin, Ma Elizabeth J. Macapagal, Aneta Chybicka, Alin Gavreliuc, Johanna Buitendach, Inge Schweiger Gallo, Emre Özgen, Ülkä E. Gäner, Nil Yamakoǧlu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

61 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The motive to attain a distinctive identity is sometimes thought to be stronger in, or even specific to, those socialized into individualistic cultures. Using data from 4,751 participants in 21 cultural groups (18 nations and 3 regions), we tested this prediction against our alternative view that culture would moderate the ways in which people achieve feelings of distinctiveness, rather than influence the strength of their motivation to do so. We measured the distinctiveness motive using an indirect technique to avoid cultural response biases. Analyses showed that the distinctiveness motive was not weaker-and, if anything, was stronger-in more collectivistic nations. However, individualism-collectivism was found to moderate the ways in which feelings of distinctiveness were constructed: Distinctiveness was associated more closely with difference and separateness in more individualistic cultures and was associated more closely with social position in more collectivistic cultures. Multilevel analysis confirmed that it is the prevailing beliefs and values in an individual's context, rather than the individual's own beliefs and values, that account for these differences.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)833-855
Number of pages23
JournalJournal of Personality and Social Psychology
Volume102
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Emotions
Multilevel Analysis
Motivation
collectivism
social position
multi-level analysis
individualism
Values
trend
Group

Keywords

  • Culture
  • Distinctiveness
  • Identity
  • Individualistic cultures
  • Motivation
  • Self-concept

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Social Psychology
  • Sociology and Political Science

Cite this

Becker, M., Vignoles, V. L., Owe, E., Brown, R., Smith, P. B., Easterbrook, M., ... Yamakoǧlu, N. (2012). Culture and the distinctiveness motive: Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 102(4), 833-855. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026853

Culture and the distinctiveness motive : Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts. / Becker, Maja; Vignoles, Vivian L.; Owe, Ellinor; Brown, Rupert; Smith, Peter B.; Easterbrook, Matt; Herman, Ginette; De Sauvage, Isabelle; Bourguignon, David; Torres, Ana; Camino, Leoncio; Lemos, Flávia Cristina Silveira; Ferreira, M. Cristina; Koller, Silvia H.; Gonzãlez, Roberto; Carrasco, Diego; Cadena, Maria Paz; Lay, Siugmin; Wang, Qian; Bond, Michael Harris; Trujillo, Elvia Vargas; Balanta, Paola; Valk, Aune; Mekonnen, Kassahun Habtamu; Nizharadze, George; Fülöp, Marta; Regalia, Camillo; Manzi, Claudia; Brambilla, Maria; Harb, Charles; Aldhafri, Said; Martin, Mariana; Macapagal, Ma Elizabeth J.; Chybicka, Aneta; Gavreliuc, Alin; Buitendach, Johanna; Gallo, Inge Schweiger; Özgen, Emre; Gäner, Ülkä E.; Yamakoǧlu, Nil.

In: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. 102, No. 4, 04.2012, p. 833-855.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Becker, M, Vignoles, VL, Owe, E, Brown, R, Smith, PB, Easterbrook, M, Herman, G, De Sauvage, I, Bourguignon, D, Torres, A, Camino, L, Lemos, FCS, Ferreira, MC, Koller, SH, Gonzãlez, R, Carrasco, D, Cadena, MP, Lay, S, Wang, Q, Bond, MH, Trujillo, EV, Balanta, P, Valk, A, Mekonnen, KH, Nizharadze, G, Fülöp, M, Regalia, C, Manzi, C, Brambilla, M, Harb, C, Aldhafri, S, Martin, M, Macapagal, MEJ, Chybicka, A, Gavreliuc, A, Buitendach, J, Gallo, IS, Özgen, E, Gäner, ÜE & Yamakoǧlu, N 2012, 'Culture and the distinctiveness motive: Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 102, no. 4, pp. 833-855. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026853
Becker, Maja ; Vignoles, Vivian L. ; Owe, Ellinor ; Brown, Rupert ; Smith, Peter B. ; Easterbrook, Matt ; Herman, Ginette ; De Sauvage, Isabelle ; Bourguignon, David ; Torres, Ana ; Camino, Leoncio ; Lemos, Flávia Cristina Silveira ; Ferreira, M. Cristina ; Koller, Silvia H. ; Gonzãlez, Roberto ; Carrasco, Diego ; Cadena, Maria Paz ; Lay, Siugmin ; Wang, Qian ; Bond, Michael Harris ; Trujillo, Elvia Vargas ; Balanta, Paola ; Valk, Aune ; Mekonnen, Kassahun Habtamu ; Nizharadze, George ; Fülöp, Marta ; Regalia, Camillo ; Manzi, Claudia ; Brambilla, Maria ; Harb, Charles ; Aldhafri, Said ; Martin, Mariana ; Macapagal, Ma Elizabeth J. ; Chybicka, Aneta ; Gavreliuc, Alin ; Buitendach, Johanna ; Gallo, Inge Schweiger ; Özgen, Emre ; Gäner, Ülkä E. ; Yamakoǧlu, Nil. / Culture and the distinctiveness motive : Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts. In: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2012 ; Vol. 102, No. 4. pp. 833-855.
@article{635c260355c74a7d9504107ea90e1963,
title = "Culture and the distinctiveness motive: Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts",
abstract = "The motive to attain a distinctive identity is sometimes thought to be stronger in, or even specific to, those socialized into individualistic cultures. Using data from 4,751 participants in 21 cultural groups (18 nations and 3 regions), we tested this prediction against our alternative view that culture would moderate the ways in which people achieve feelings of distinctiveness, rather than influence the strength of their motivation to do so. We measured the distinctiveness motive using an indirect technique to avoid cultural response biases. Analyses showed that the distinctiveness motive was not weaker-and, if anything, was stronger-in more collectivistic nations. However, individualism-collectivism was found to moderate the ways in which feelings of distinctiveness were constructed: Distinctiveness was associated more closely with difference and separateness in more individualistic cultures and was associated more closely with social position in more collectivistic cultures. Multilevel analysis confirmed that it is the prevailing beliefs and values in an individual's context, rather than the individual's own beliefs and values, that account for these differences.",
keywords = "Culture, Distinctiveness, Identity, Individualistic cultures, Motivation, Self-concept",
author = "Maja Becker and Vignoles, {Vivian L.} and Ellinor Owe and Rupert Brown and Smith, {Peter B.} and Matt Easterbrook and Ginette Herman and {De Sauvage}, Isabelle and David Bourguignon and Ana Torres and Leoncio Camino and Lemos, {Fl{\'a}via Cristina Silveira} and Ferreira, {M. Cristina} and Koller, {Silvia H.} and Roberto Gonz{\~a}lez and Diego Carrasco and Cadena, {Maria Paz} and Siugmin Lay and Qian Wang and Bond, {Michael Harris} and Trujillo, {Elvia Vargas} and Paola Balanta and Aune Valk and Mekonnen, {Kassahun Habtamu} and George Nizharadze and Marta F{\"u}l{\"o}p and Camillo Regalia and Claudia Manzi and Maria Brambilla and Charles Harb and Said Aldhafri and Mariana Martin and Macapagal, {Ma Elizabeth J.} and Aneta Chybicka and Alin Gavreliuc and Johanna Buitendach and Gallo, {Inge Schweiger} and Emre {\"O}zgen and G{\"a}ner, {{\"U}lk{\"a} E.} and Nil Yamakoǧlu",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1037/a0026853",
language = "English",
volume = "102",
pages = "833--855",
journal = "Journal of Personality and Social Psychology",
issn = "0022-3514",
publisher = "American Psychological Association Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Culture and the distinctiveness motive

T2 - Constructing identity in individualistic and collectivistic contexts

AU - Becker, Maja

AU - Vignoles, Vivian L.

AU - Owe, Ellinor

AU - Brown, Rupert

AU - Smith, Peter B.

AU - Easterbrook, Matt

AU - Herman, Ginette

AU - De Sauvage, Isabelle

AU - Bourguignon, David

AU - Torres, Ana

AU - Camino, Leoncio

AU - Lemos, Flávia Cristina Silveira

AU - Ferreira, M. Cristina

AU - Koller, Silvia H.

AU - Gonzãlez, Roberto

AU - Carrasco, Diego

AU - Cadena, Maria Paz

AU - Lay, Siugmin

AU - Wang, Qian

AU - Bond, Michael Harris

AU - Trujillo, Elvia Vargas

AU - Balanta, Paola

AU - Valk, Aune

AU - Mekonnen, Kassahun Habtamu

AU - Nizharadze, George

AU - Fülöp, Marta

AU - Regalia, Camillo

AU - Manzi, Claudia

AU - Brambilla, Maria

AU - Harb, Charles

AU - Aldhafri, Said

AU - Martin, Mariana

AU - Macapagal, Ma Elizabeth J.

AU - Chybicka, Aneta

AU - Gavreliuc, Alin

AU - Buitendach, Johanna

AU - Gallo, Inge Schweiger

AU - Özgen, Emre

AU - Gäner, Ülkä E.

AU - Yamakoǧlu, Nil

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - The motive to attain a distinctive identity is sometimes thought to be stronger in, or even specific to, those socialized into individualistic cultures. Using data from 4,751 participants in 21 cultural groups (18 nations and 3 regions), we tested this prediction against our alternative view that culture would moderate the ways in which people achieve feelings of distinctiveness, rather than influence the strength of their motivation to do so. We measured the distinctiveness motive using an indirect technique to avoid cultural response biases. Analyses showed that the distinctiveness motive was not weaker-and, if anything, was stronger-in more collectivistic nations. However, individualism-collectivism was found to moderate the ways in which feelings of distinctiveness were constructed: Distinctiveness was associated more closely with difference and separateness in more individualistic cultures and was associated more closely with social position in more collectivistic cultures. Multilevel analysis confirmed that it is the prevailing beliefs and values in an individual's context, rather than the individual's own beliefs and values, that account for these differences.

AB - The motive to attain a distinctive identity is sometimes thought to be stronger in, or even specific to, those socialized into individualistic cultures. Using data from 4,751 participants in 21 cultural groups (18 nations and 3 regions), we tested this prediction against our alternative view that culture would moderate the ways in which people achieve feelings of distinctiveness, rather than influence the strength of their motivation to do so. We measured the distinctiveness motive using an indirect technique to avoid cultural response biases. Analyses showed that the distinctiveness motive was not weaker-and, if anything, was stronger-in more collectivistic nations. However, individualism-collectivism was found to moderate the ways in which feelings of distinctiveness were constructed: Distinctiveness was associated more closely with difference and separateness in more individualistic cultures and was associated more closely with social position in more collectivistic cultures. Multilevel analysis confirmed that it is the prevailing beliefs and values in an individual's context, rather than the individual's own beliefs and values, that account for these differences.

KW - Culture

KW - Distinctiveness

KW - Identity

KW - Individualistic cultures

KW - Motivation

KW - Self-concept

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84864517107&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84864517107&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/a0026853

DO - 10.1037/a0026853

M3 - Article

VL - 102

SP - 833

EP - 855

JO - Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

JF - Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

SN - 0022-3514

IS - 4

ER -