The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction

Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World

Thomas Li Ping Tang, Toto Sutarso, Adebowale Akande, Michael W. Allen, Abdulgawi Salim Alzubaidi, Mahfooz A. Ansari, Fernando Arias-Galicia, Mark G. Borg, Luigina Canova, Brigitte Charles-Pauvers, Bor Shiuan Cheng, Randy K. Chiu, Linzhi Du, Ilya Garber, Consuelo Garcia De La Torre, Rosario Correia Higgs, Abdul Hamid Safwat Ibrahim, Chin Kang Jen, Ali Mahdi Kazem, Kilsun Kim & 21 others Vivien Kim Geok Lim, Roberto Luna-Arocas, Eva Malovics, Anna Maria Manganelli, Alice S. Moreira, Anthony Ugochukwu Obiajulu Nnedum, Johnsto E. Osagie, AAhad M. Osman-Gani, Francisco Costa Pereira, Ruja Pholsward, Horia D. Pitariu, Marko Polic, Elisaveta Sardzoska, Petar Skobic, Allen F. Stembridge, Theresa Li Na Tang, Thompson Sian Hin Teo, Marco Tombolani, Martina Trontelj, Caroline Urbain, Peter Vlerick

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

51 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Demonstrating the equivalence of constructs is a key requirement for cross- cultural empirical research. The major purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how to assess measurement and functional equivalence or invariance using the 9-item, 3-factor Love of Money Scale (LOMS, a second-order factor model) and the 4-item, 1-factor Pay Level Satisfaction Scale (PLSS, a first-order factor model) across 29 samples in six continents (N = 5973). In step 1, we tested the configural, metric and scalar invariance of the LOMS and 17 samples achieved measurement invariance. In step 2, we applied the same procedures to the PLSS and nine samples achieved measurement invariance. Five samples (Brazil, China, South Africa, Spain and the USA) passed the measurement invariance criteria for both measures. In step 3, we found that for these two measures, common method variance was non-significant. In step 4, we tested the functional equivalence between the Love of Money Scale and Pay Level Satisfaction Scale. We achieved functional equivalence for these two scales in all five samples. The results of this study suggest the critical importance of evaluating and establishing measurement equivalence in cross-cultural studies. Suggestions for remedying measurement non-equivalence are offered.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)423-452
Number of pages30
JournalManagement and Organization Review
Volume2
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Fingerprint

The love of money
Equivalence
Measurement invariance
Invariance
Factors
Spain
Cross-cultural studies
Measurement equivalence
Common method variance
South Africa
China
Brazil
Empirical research

Keywords

  • 29 geopolitical entities
  • cross-cultural empirical research
  • functional equivalence
  • measurement invariance
  • pay level satisfaction
  • the love of money

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Business and International Management
  • Strategy and Management

Cite this

The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction : Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World. / Tang, Thomas Li Ping; Sutarso, Toto; Akande, Adebowale; Allen, Michael W.; Alzubaidi, Abdulgawi Salim; Ansari, Mahfooz A.; Arias-Galicia, Fernando; Borg, Mark G.; Canova, Luigina; Charles-Pauvers, Brigitte; Cheng, Bor Shiuan; Chiu, Randy K.; Du, Linzhi; Garber, Ilya; De La Torre, Consuelo Garcia; Higgs, Rosario Correia; Safwat Ibrahim, Abdul Hamid; Jen, Chin Kang; Kazem, Ali Mahdi; Kim, Kilsun; Geok Lim, Vivien Kim; Luna-Arocas, Roberto; Malovics, Eva; Manganelli, Anna Maria; Moreira, Alice S.; Obiajulu Nnedum, Anthony Ugochukwu; Osagie, Johnsto E.; Osman-Gani, AAhad M.; Pereira, Francisco Costa; Pholsward, Ruja; Pitariu, Horia D.; Polic, Marko; Sardzoska, Elisaveta; Skobic, Petar; Stembridge, Allen F.; Tang, Theresa Li Na; Hin Teo, Thompson Sian; Tombolani, Marco; Trontelj, Martina; Urbain, Caroline; Vlerick, Peter.

In: Management and Organization Review, Vol. 2, No. 3, 2006, p. 423-452.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tang, TLP, Sutarso, T, Akande, A, Allen, MW, Alzubaidi, AS, Ansari, MA, Arias-Galicia, F, Borg, MG, Canova, L, Charles-Pauvers, B, Cheng, BS, Chiu, RK, Du, L, Garber, I, De La Torre, CG, Higgs, RC, Safwat Ibrahim, AH, Jen, CK, Kazem, AM, Kim, K, Geok Lim, VK, Luna-Arocas, R, Malovics, E, Manganelli, AM, Moreira, AS, Obiajulu Nnedum, AU, Osagie, JE, Osman-Gani, AAM, Pereira, FC, Pholsward, R, Pitariu, HD, Polic, M, Sardzoska, E, Skobic, P, Stembridge, AF, Tang, TLN, Hin Teo, TS, Tombolani, M, Trontelj, M, Urbain, C & Vlerick, P 2006, 'The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction: Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World', Management and Organization Review, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 423-452. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1740-8784.2006.00051.x
Tang, Thomas Li Ping ; Sutarso, Toto ; Akande, Adebowale ; Allen, Michael W. ; Alzubaidi, Abdulgawi Salim ; Ansari, Mahfooz A. ; Arias-Galicia, Fernando ; Borg, Mark G. ; Canova, Luigina ; Charles-Pauvers, Brigitte ; Cheng, Bor Shiuan ; Chiu, Randy K. ; Du, Linzhi ; Garber, Ilya ; De La Torre, Consuelo Garcia ; Higgs, Rosario Correia ; Safwat Ibrahim, Abdul Hamid ; Jen, Chin Kang ; Kazem, Ali Mahdi ; Kim, Kilsun ; Geok Lim, Vivien Kim ; Luna-Arocas, Roberto ; Malovics, Eva ; Manganelli, Anna Maria ; Moreira, Alice S. ; Obiajulu Nnedum, Anthony Ugochukwu ; Osagie, Johnsto E. ; Osman-Gani, AAhad M. ; Pereira, Francisco Costa ; Pholsward, Ruja ; Pitariu, Horia D. ; Polic, Marko ; Sardzoska, Elisaveta ; Skobic, Petar ; Stembridge, Allen F. ; Tang, Theresa Li Na ; Hin Teo, Thompson Sian ; Tombolani, Marco ; Trontelj, Martina ; Urbain, Caroline ; Vlerick, Peter. / The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction : Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World. In: Management and Organization Review. 2006 ; Vol. 2, No. 3. pp. 423-452.
@article{646e349c3a7e44a3a86be2ae1fbfb69f,
title = "The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction: Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World",
abstract = "Demonstrating the equivalence of constructs is a key requirement for cross- cultural empirical research. The major purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how to assess measurement and functional equivalence or invariance using the 9-item, 3-factor Love of Money Scale (LOMS, a second-order factor model) and the 4-item, 1-factor Pay Level Satisfaction Scale (PLSS, a first-order factor model) across 29 samples in six continents (N = 5973). In step 1, we tested the configural, metric and scalar invariance of the LOMS and 17 samples achieved measurement invariance. In step 2, we applied the same procedures to the PLSS and nine samples achieved measurement invariance. Five samples (Brazil, China, South Africa, Spain and the USA) passed the measurement invariance criteria for both measures. In step 3, we found that for these two measures, common method variance was non-significant. In step 4, we tested the functional equivalence between the Love of Money Scale and Pay Level Satisfaction Scale. We achieved functional equivalence for these two scales in all five samples. The results of this study suggest the critical importance of evaluating and establishing measurement equivalence in cross-cultural studies. Suggestions for remedying measurement non-equivalence are offered.",
keywords = "29 geopolitical entities, cross-cultural empirical research, functional equivalence, measurement invariance, pay level satisfaction, the love of money",
author = "Tang, {Thomas Li Ping} and Toto Sutarso and Adebowale Akande and Allen, {Michael W.} and Alzubaidi, {Abdulgawi Salim} and Ansari, {Mahfooz A.} and Fernando Arias-Galicia and Borg, {Mark G.} and Luigina Canova and Brigitte Charles-Pauvers and Cheng, {Bor Shiuan} and Chiu, {Randy K.} and Linzhi Du and Ilya Garber and {De La Torre}, {Consuelo Garcia} and Higgs, {Rosario Correia} and {Safwat Ibrahim}, {Abdul Hamid} and Jen, {Chin Kang} and Kazem, {Ali Mahdi} and Kilsun Kim and {Geok Lim}, {Vivien Kim} and Roberto Luna-Arocas and Eva Malovics and Manganelli, {Anna Maria} and Moreira, {Alice S.} and {Obiajulu Nnedum}, {Anthony Ugochukwu} and Osagie, {Johnsto E.} and Osman-Gani, {AAhad M.} and Pereira, {Francisco Costa} and Ruja Pholsward and Pitariu, {Horia D.} and Marko Polic and Elisaveta Sardzoska and Petar Skobic and Stembridge, {Allen F.} and Tang, {Theresa Li Na} and {Hin Teo}, {Thompson Sian} and Marco Tombolani and Martina Trontelj and Caroline Urbain and Peter Vlerick",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1111/j.1740-8784.2006.00051.x",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
pages = "423--452",
journal = "Management and Organization Review",
issn = "1740-8776",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Love of Money and Pay Level Satisfaction

T2 - Measurement and Functional Equivalence in 29 Geopolitical Entities around the World

AU - Tang, Thomas Li Ping

AU - Sutarso, Toto

AU - Akande, Adebowale

AU - Allen, Michael W.

AU - Alzubaidi, Abdulgawi Salim

AU - Ansari, Mahfooz A.

AU - Arias-Galicia, Fernando

AU - Borg, Mark G.

AU - Canova, Luigina

AU - Charles-Pauvers, Brigitte

AU - Cheng, Bor Shiuan

AU - Chiu, Randy K.

AU - Du, Linzhi

AU - Garber, Ilya

AU - De La Torre, Consuelo Garcia

AU - Higgs, Rosario Correia

AU - Safwat Ibrahim, Abdul Hamid

AU - Jen, Chin Kang

AU - Kazem, Ali Mahdi

AU - Kim, Kilsun

AU - Geok Lim, Vivien Kim

AU - Luna-Arocas, Roberto

AU - Malovics, Eva

AU - Manganelli, Anna Maria

AU - Moreira, Alice S.

AU - Obiajulu Nnedum, Anthony Ugochukwu

AU - Osagie, Johnsto E.

AU - Osman-Gani, AAhad M.

AU - Pereira, Francisco Costa

AU - Pholsward, Ruja

AU - Pitariu, Horia D.

AU - Polic, Marko

AU - Sardzoska, Elisaveta

AU - Skobic, Petar

AU - Stembridge, Allen F.

AU - Tang, Theresa Li Na

AU - Hin Teo, Thompson Sian

AU - Tombolani, Marco

AU - Trontelj, Martina

AU - Urbain, Caroline

AU - Vlerick, Peter

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Demonstrating the equivalence of constructs is a key requirement for cross- cultural empirical research. The major purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how to assess measurement and functional equivalence or invariance using the 9-item, 3-factor Love of Money Scale (LOMS, a second-order factor model) and the 4-item, 1-factor Pay Level Satisfaction Scale (PLSS, a first-order factor model) across 29 samples in six continents (N = 5973). In step 1, we tested the configural, metric and scalar invariance of the LOMS and 17 samples achieved measurement invariance. In step 2, we applied the same procedures to the PLSS and nine samples achieved measurement invariance. Five samples (Brazil, China, South Africa, Spain and the USA) passed the measurement invariance criteria for both measures. In step 3, we found that for these two measures, common method variance was non-significant. In step 4, we tested the functional equivalence between the Love of Money Scale and Pay Level Satisfaction Scale. We achieved functional equivalence for these two scales in all five samples. The results of this study suggest the critical importance of evaluating and establishing measurement equivalence in cross-cultural studies. Suggestions for remedying measurement non-equivalence are offered.

AB - Demonstrating the equivalence of constructs is a key requirement for cross- cultural empirical research. The major purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how to assess measurement and functional equivalence or invariance using the 9-item, 3-factor Love of Money Scale (LOMS, a second-order factor model) and the 4-item, 1-factor Pay Level Satisfaction Scale (PLSS, a first-order factor model) across 29 samples in six continents (N = 5973). In step 1, we tested the configural, metric and scalar invariance of the LOMS and 17 samples achieved measurement invariance. In step 2, we applied the same procedures to the PLSS and nine samples achieved measurement invariance. Five samples (Brazil, China, South Africa, Spain and the USA) passed the measurement invariance criteria for both measures. In step 3, we found that for these two measures, common method variance was non-significant. In step 4, we tested the functional equivalence between the Love of Money Scale and Pay Level Satisfaction Scale. We achieved functional equivalence for these two scales in all five samples. The results of this study suggest the critical importance of evaluating and establishing measurement equivalence in cross-cultural studies. Suggestions for remedying measurement non-equivalence are offered.

KW - 29 geopolitical entities

KW - cross-cultural empirical research

KW - functional equivalence

KW - measurement invariance

KW - pay level satisfaction

KW - the love of money

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34248636879&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34248636879&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1740-8784.2006.00051.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1740-8784.2006.00051.x

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 423

EP - 452

JO - Management and Organization Review

JF - Management and Organization Review

SN - 1740-8776

IS - 3

ER -