Teachers’ school guidance practice toward PISA enhancement

A comparison between Malaysia and Finland

Nurshida Mohd Ishak, Hussein Ismail, Byabazaire Yusuf

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the practice of school guidance. In addition, it is aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of PISA and its significance and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the school guidance practice towards PISA enhancement. This study is a qualitative research, employing semi-structured interviews with four subject teachers; two participants from Finland and two participants from Malaysia. The study uses a purposive sample and the sample size consists of 4 participants. The selected interviewees are teachers in secondary schools in both countries. The data collected are analysed using three phases of thematic analysis with the help of analysis computer software, Nvivo for a more visible systematic analysis. Teachers have different interpretations of what constitutes school guidance; its meaning, definition, framework. Additionally, the personnel involved in school guidance differs in Malaysia and Finland. In terms of the teaching context, participant teachers in consensus agreed that PISA assessment plays little role in the determination of what they believe is important for their students’ needs (skills) to survive in their life after school. School guidance has the potential to contribute towards PISA enhancement if and when the school guidance programme is financially supported plus a strong support or desire from students, teachers, counsellors and the school administration as a whole.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)337-368
Number of pages32
JournalAl-Shajarah
Issue numberSpecial Issue: EDUCATION
Publication statusPublished - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

Finland
Malaysia
subject teacher
teacher
school
school administration
role play
Guidance
Enhancement
counselor
student teacher
qualitative research
secondary school
personnel
interpretation
Teaching
interview
student

Keywords

  • Comparative study
  • Educational system
  • Finland
  • Malaysia
  • PISA
  • School guidance
  • Teacher

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cultural Studies
  • History
  • Religious studies
  • Philosophy

Cite this

Teachers’ school guidance practice toward PISA enhancement : A comparison between Malaysia and Finland. / Ishak, Nurshida Mohd; Ismail, Hussein; Yusuf, Byabazaire.

In: Al-Shajarah, No. Special Issue: EDUCATION, 01.01.2018, p. 337-368.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ishak, Nurshida Mohd ; Ismail, Hussein ; Yusuf, Byabazaire. / Teachers’ school guidance practice toward PISA enhancement : A comparison between Malaysia and Finland. In: Al-Shajarah. 2018 ; No. Special Issue: EDUCATION. pp. 337-368.
@article{777c00815ca94948bde27e53b6f52da7,
title = "Teachers’ school guidance practice toward PISA enhancement: A comparison between Malaysia and Finland",
abstract = "This study aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the practice of school guidance. In addition, it is aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of PISA and its significance and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the school guidance practice towards PISA enhancement. This study is a qualitative research, employing semi-structured interviews with four subject teachers; two participants from Finland and two participants from Malaysia. The study uses a purposive sample and the sample size consists of 4 participants. The selected interviewees are teachers in secondary schools in both countries. The data collected are analysed using three phases of thematic analysis with the help of analysis computer software, Nvivo for a more visible systematic analysis. Teachers have different interpretations of what constitutes school guidance; its meaning, definition, framework. Additionally, the personnel involved in school guidance differs in Malaysia and Finland. In terms of the teaching context, participant teachers in consensus agreed that PISA assessment plays little role in the determination of what they believe is important for their students’ needs (skills) to survive in their life after school. School guidance has the potential to contribute towards PISA enhancement if and when the school guidance programme is financially supported plus a strong support or desire from students, teachers, counsellors and the school administration as a whole.",
keywords = "Comparative study, Educational system, Finland, Malaysia, PISA, School guidance, Teacher",
author = "Ishak, {Nurshida Mohd} and Hussein Ismail and Byabazaire Yusuf",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
pages = "337--368",
journal = "Al-Shajarah",
issn = "1394-6870",
publisher = "International Islamic University Malaysia",
number = "Special Issue: EDUCATION",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Teachers’ school guidance practice toward PISA enhancement

T2 - A comparison between Malaysia and Finland

AU - Ishak, Nurshida Mohd

AU - Ismail, Hussein

AU - Yusuf, Byabazaire

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - This study aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the practice of school guidance. In addition, it is aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of PISA and its significance and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the school guidance practice towards PISA enhancement. This study is a qualitative research, employing semi-structured interviews with four subject teachers; two participants from Finland and two participants from Malaysia. The study uses a purposive sample and the sample size consists of 4 participants. The selected interviewees are teachers in secondary schools in both countries. The data collected are analysed using three phases of thematic analysis with the help of analysis computer software, Nvivo for a more visible systematic analysis. Teachers have different interpretations of what constitutes school guidance; its meaning, definition, framework. Additionally, the personnel involved in school guidance differs in Malaysia and Finland. In terms of the teaching context, participant teachers in consensus agreed that PISA assessment plays little role in the determination of what they believe is important for their students’ needs (skills) to survive in their life after school. School guidance has the potential to contribute towards PISA enhancement if and when the school guidance programme is financially supported plus a strong support or desire from students, teachers, counsellors and the school administration as a whole.

AB - This study aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the practice of school guidance. In addition, it is aimed to compare Malaysian and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of PISA and its significance and Finnish subject teachers’ perceptions of the school guidance practice towards PISA enhancement. This study is a qualitative research, employing semi-structured interviews with four subject teachers; two participants from Finland and two participants from Malaysia. The study uses a purposive sample and the sample size consists of 4 participants. The selected interviewees are teachers in secondary schools in both countries. The data collected are analysed using three phases of thematic analysis with the help of analysis computer software, Nvivo for a more visible systematic analysis. Teachers have different interpretations of what constitutes school guidance; its meaning, definition, framework. Additionally, the personnel involved in school guidance differs in Malaysia and Finland. In terms of the teaching context, participant teachers in consensus agreed that PISA assessment plays little role in the determination of what they believe is important for their students’ needs (skills) to survive in their life after school. School guidance has the potential to contribute towards PISA enhancement if and when the school guidance programme is financially supported plus a strong support or desire from students, teachers, counsellors and the school administration as a whole.

KW - Comparative study

KW - Educational system

KW - Finland

KW - Malaysia

KW - PISA

KW - School guidance

KW - Teacher

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85059639815&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85059639815&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

SP - 337

EP - 368

JO - Al-Shajarah

JF - Al-Shajarah

SN - 1394-6870

IS - Special Issue: EDUCATION

ER -