Evaluation of the taxonomic sufficiency approach for ichthyoplankton community analysis

Frank J. Hernandez, Laure Carassou, William M. Graham, Sean P. Powers

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Ichthyoplankton identification is a time-consuming task, and often larvae cannot be identified to species due to a lack of adequate early life history descriptions. As a result, ichthyoplankton assemblage data are often analyzed at the family level, which results in a loss of taxonomic resolution, or at mixed taxonomic levels (e.g. family, genus and species combined), which can lead to difficulties in interpretation of results when a single species is included in multiple taxo nomic groupings. The taxonomic sufficiency (TS) approach has been used extensively in other disciplines (e.g. benthic marine macrofauna) to address similar analytical constraints, but to date this method has not been rigorously examined for ichthyoplankton studies. In this study, an ichthyoplankton data set collected in the northern Gulf of Mexico was proportioned into 3 data subsets with varying levels of taxonomic resolution: (1) species level only; (2) species, genus and family levels; and (3) combined taxonomic levels. Comparisons were made for assemblage metrics (larval density, richness and diversity) calculated for each taxonomic subset, as well as multivariate analyses of temporal variations characterizing ichthyoplankton assemblages. Genus- and species-level similarity matrices were highly correlated, which suggests analyses at the genus level could serve as a good proxy for species when examining assemblage diversity. Multivariate results for seasonal patterns were similar among family-, genus- and species-level analyses. The common approach of analyzing ichthyoplankton assemblages at mixed taxonomic levels, however, is not as statistically rigorous as single taxonomic-level analyses.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)77-90
Number of pages14
JournalMarine Ecology Progress Series
Volume491
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2 2013

Fingerprint

ichthyoplankton
Gulf of Mexico
temporal variation
evaluation
analysis
seasonal variation
life history
larvae
larva
matrix
family

Keywords

  • Gulf of mexico
  • Larval fish
  • Multivariate community analyses
  • Seasonality
  • Taxonomic resolution

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science
  • Ecology
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Evaluation of the taxonomic sufficiency approach for ichthyoplankton community analysis. / Hernandez, Frank J.; Carassou, Laure; Graham, William M.; Powers, Sean P.

In: Marine Ecology Progress Series, Vol. 491, 02.10.2013, p. 77-90.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hernandez, Frank J. ; Carassou, Laure ; Graham, William M. ; Powers, Sean P. / Evaluation of the taxonomic sufficiency approach for ichthyoplankton community analysis. In: Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2013 ; Vol. 491. pp. 77-90.
@article{60c5525b6a474f27ab0b72b905de2789,
title = "Evaluation of the taxonomic sufficiency approach for ichthyoplankton community analysis",
abstract = "Ichthyoplankton identification is a time-consuming task, and often larvae cannot be identified to species due to a lack of adequate early life history descriptions. As a result, ichthyoplankton assemblage data are often analyzed at the family level, which results in a loss of taxonomic resolution, or at mixed taxonomic levels (e.g. family, genus and species combined), which can lead to difficulties in interpretation of results when a single species is included in multiple taxo nomic groupings. The taxonomic sufficiency (TS) approach has been used extensively in other disciplines (e.g. benthic marine macrofauna) to address similar analytical constraints, but to date this method has not been rigorously examined for ichthyoplankton studies. In this study, an ichthyoplankton data set collected in the northern Gulf of Mexico was proportioned into 3 data subsets with varying levels of taxonomic resolution: (1) species level only; (2) species, genus and family levels; and (3) combined taxonomic levels. Comparisons were made for assemblage metrics (larval density, richness and diversity) calculated for each taxonomic subset, as well as multivariate analyses of temporal variations characterizing ichthyoplankton assemblages. Genus- and species-level similarity matrices were highly correlated, which suggests analyses at the genus level could serve as a good proxy for species when examining assemblage diversity. Multivariate results for seasonal patterns were similar among family-, genus- and species-level analyses. The common approach of analyzing ichthyoplankton assemblages at mixed taxonomic levels, however, is not as statistically rigorous as single taxonomic-level analyses.",
keywords = "Gulf of mexico, Larval fish, Multivariate community analyses, Seasonality, Taxonomic resolution",
author = "Hernandez, {Frank J.} and Laure Carassou and Graham, {William M.} and Powers, {Sean P.}",
year = "2013",
month = "10",
day = "2",
doi = "10.3354/meps10475",
language = "English",
volume = "491",
pages = "77--90",
journal = "Marine Ecology - Progress Series",
issn = "0171-8630",
publisher = "Inter-Research",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of the taxonomic sufficiency approach for ichthyoplankton community analysis

AU - Hernandez, Frank J.

AU - Carassou, Laure

AU - Graham, William M.

AU - Powers, Sean P.

PY - 2013/10/2

Y1 - 2013/10/2

N2 - Ichthyoplankton identification is a time-consuming task, and often larvae cannot be identified to species due to a lack of adequate early life history descriptions. As a result, ichthyoplankton assemblage data are often analyzed at the family level, which results in a loss of taxonomic resolution, or at mixed taxonomic levels (e.g. family, genus and species combined), which can lead to difficulties in interpretation of results when a single species is included in multiple taxo nomic groupings. The taxonomic sufficiency (TS) approach has been used extensively in other disciplines (e.g. benthic marine macrofauna) to address similar analytical constraints, but to date this method has not been rigorously examined for ichthyoplankton studies. In this study, an ichthyoplankton data set collected in the northern Gulf of Mexico was proportioned into 3 data subsets with varying levels of taxonomic resolution: (1) species level only; (2) species, genus and family levels; and (3) combined taxonomic levels. Comparisons were made for assemblage metrics (larval density, richness and diversity) calculated for each taxonomic subset, as well as multivariate analyses of temporal variations characterizing ichthyoplankton assemblages. Genus- and species-level similarity matrices were highly correlated, which suggests analyses at the genus level could serve as a good proxy for species when examining assemblage diversity. Multivariate results for seasonal patterns were similar among family-, genus- and species-level analyses. The common approach of analyzing ichthyoplankton assemblages at mixed taxonomic levels, however, is not as statistically rigorous as single taxonomic-level analyses.

AB - Ichthyoplankton identification is a time-consuming task, and often larvae cannot be identified to species due to a lack of adequate early life history descriptions. As a result, ichthyoplankton assemblage data are often analyzed at the family level, which results in a loss of taxonomic resolution, or at mixed taxonomic levels (e.g. family, genus and species combined), which can lead to difficulties in interpretation of results when a single species is included in multiple taxo nomic groupings. The taxonomic sufficiency (TS) approach has been used extensively in other disciplines (e.g. benthic marine macrofauna) to address similar analytical constraints, but to date this method has not been rigorously examined for ichthyoplankton studies. In this study, an ichthyoplankton data set collected in the northern Gulf of Mexico was proportioned into 3 data subsets with varying levels of taxonomic resolution: (1) species level only; (2) species, genus and family levels; and (3) combined taxonomic levels. Comparisons were made for assemblage metrics (larval density, richness and diversity) calculated for each taxonomic subset, as well as multivariate analyses of temporal variations characterizing ichthyoplankton assemblages. Genus- and species-level similarity matrices were highly correlated, which suggests analyses at the genus level could serve as a good proxy for species when examining assemblage diversity. Multivariate results for seasonal patterns were similar among family-, genus- and species-level analyses. The common approach of analyzing ichthyoplankton assemblages at mixed taxonomic levels, however, is not as statistically rigorous as single taxonomic-level analyses.

KW - Gulf of mexico

KW - Larval fish

KW - Multivariate community analyses

KW - Seasonality

KW - Taxonomic resolution

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84885045724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84885045724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3354/meps10475

DO - 10.3354/meps10475

M3 - Article

VL - 491

SP - 77

EP - 90

JO - Marine Ecology - Progress Series

JF - Marine Ecology - Progress Series

SN - 0171-8630

ER -