An efficient optimization of well placement and control for a geothermal prospect under geological uncertainty

Mingjie Chen, Andrew F B Tompson, Robert J. Mellors, Osman Abdalla

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study applies an efficient optimization technique based on a multivariate adaptive regression spline (MARS) technique to determine the optimal design and engineering of a potential geothermal production operation at a prospect near Superstition Mountain in Southern California, USA. The faster MARS-based statistical model is used as a surrogate for higher-fidelity physical models within the intensive optimization process. Its use allows for the exploration of the impacts of specific engineering design parameters in the context of geologic uncertainty as a means to both understand and maximize profitability of the production operation. The MARS model is initially developed from a training dataset generated by a finite set of computationally complex hydrothermal models applied to the prospect. Its application reveals that the optimal engineering design variables can differ considerably assuming different choices of hydrothermal flow properties, which, in turn, indicates the importance of reducing the uncertainty of key geologic properties. The major uncertainty sources in the natural-system are identified and ranked first by an efficient MARS-enabled total order sensitivity quantification, which is then used to assist evaluating the effect of geological uncertainties on optimized results. At the Southern California prospect, this parameter sensitivity analysis suggests that groundwater circulation through high permeable structures, rather than heat conduction through impermeable granite, is the primary heat transfer method during geothermal extraction. Reservoir histories simulated using optimal parameters with different constraints are analyzed and compared to investigate the longevity and maximum profit of the geothermal resources. The comparison shows that the longevity and profit are very likely to be overestimated by optimizations without appropriate constraints on natural conditions. In addition to geothermal energy production, this optimization approach can also be used to manage other geologic resource operations, such as hydrocarbon production or CO2 sequestration, under uncertain reservoir conditions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)352-363
Number of pages12
JournalApplied Energy
Volume137
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Splines
Profitability
engineering
Geothermal energy
Granite
geothermal energy
resource
Heat conduction
profitability
carbon sequestration
Sensitivity analysis
heat transfer
sensitivity analysis
Groundwater
granite
Hydrocarbons
hydrocarbon
Heat transfer
mountain
groundwater

Keywords

  • Geothermal
  • Optimization
  • Sensitivity
  • Surrogate
  • Uncertainty

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Energy(all)
  • Civil and Structural Engineering

Cite this

An efficient optimization of well placement and control for a geothermal prospect under geological uncertainty. / Chen, Mingjie; Tompson, Andrew F B; Mellors, Robert J.; Abdalla, Osman.

In: Applied Energy, Vol. 137, 2015, p. 352-363.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1ed5ef8e04e046b6a6878cd413f178a0,
title = "An efficient optimization of well placement and control for a geothermal prospect under geological uncertainty",
abstract = "This study applies an efficient optimization technique based on a multivariate adaptive regression spline (MARS) technique to determine the optimal design and engineering of a potential geothermal production operation at a prospect near Superstition Mountain in Southern California, USA. The faster MARS-based statistical model is used as a surrogate for higher-fidelity physical models within the intensive optimization process. Its use allows for the exploration of the impacts of specific engineering design parameters in the context of geologic uncertainty as a means to both understand and maximize profitability of the production operation. The MARS model is initially developed from a training dataset generated by a finite set of computationally complex hydrothermal models applied to the prospect. Its application reveals that the optimal engineering design variables can differ considerably assuming different choices of hydrothermal flow properties, which, in turn, indicates the importance of reducing the uncertainty of key geologic properties. The major uncertainty sources in the natural-system are identified and ranked first by an efficient MARS-enabled total order sensitivity quantification, which is then used to assist evaluating the effect of geological uncertainties on optimized results. At the Southern California prospect, this parameter sensitivity analysis suggests that groundwater circulation through high permeable structures, rather than heat conduction through impermeable granite, is the primary heat transfer method during geothermal extraction. Reservoir histories simulated using optimal parameters with different constraints are analyzed and compared to investigate the longevity and maximum profit of the geothermal resources. The comparison shows that the longevity and profit are very likely to be overestimated by optimizations without appropriate constraints on natural conditions. In addition to geothermal energy production, this optimization approach can also be used to manage other geologic resource operations, such as hydrocarbon production or CO2 sequestration, under uncertain reservoir conditions.",
keywords = "Geothermal, Optimization, Sensitivity, Surrogate, Uncertainty",
author = "Mingjie Chen and Tompson, {Andrew F B} and Mellors, {Robert J.} and Osman Abdalla",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.10.036",
language = "English",
volume = "137",
pages = "352--363",
journal = "Applied Energy",
issn = "0306-2619",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An efficient optimization of well placement and control for a geothermal prospect under geological uncertainty

AU - Chen, Mingjie

AU - Tompson, Andrew F B

AU - Mellors, Robert J.

AU - Abdalla, Osman

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - This study applies an efficient optimization technique based on a multivariate adaptive regression spline (MARS) technique to determine the optimal design and engineering of a potential geothermal production operation at a prospect near Superstition Mountain in Southern California, USA. The faster MARS-based statistical model is used as a surrogate for higher-fidelity physical models within the intensive optimization process. Its use allows for the exploration of the impacts of specific engineering design parameters in the context of geologic uncertainty as a means to both understand and maximize profitability of the production operation. The MARS model is initially developed from a training dataset generated by a finite set of computationally complex hydrothermal models applied to the prospect. Its application reveals that the optimal engineering design variables can differ considerably assuming different choices of hydrothermal flow properties, which, in turn, indicates the importance of reducing the uncertainty of key geologic properties. The major uncertainty sources in the natural-system are identified and ranked first by an efficient MARS-enabled total order sensitivity quantification, which is then used to assist evaluating the effect of geological uncertainties on optimized results. At the Southern California prospect, this parameter sensitivity analysis suggests that groundwater circulation through high permeable structures, rather than heat conduction through impermeable granite, is the primary heat transfer method during geothermal extraction. Reservoir histories simulated using optimal parameters with different constraints are analyzed and compared to investigate the longevity and maximum profit of the geothermal resources. The comparison shows that the longevity and profit are very likely to be overestimated by optimizations without appropriate constraints on natural conditions. In addition to geothermal energy production, this optimization approach can also be used to manage other geologic resource operations, such as hydrocarbon production or CO2 sequestration, under uncertain reservoir conditions.

AB - This study applies an efficient optimization technique based on a multivariate adaptive regression spline (MARS) technique to determine the optimal design and engineering of a potential geothermal production operation at a prospect near Superstition Mountain in Southern California, USA. The faster MARS-based statistical model is used as a surrogate for higher-fidelity physical models within the intensive optimization process. Its use allows for the exploration of the impacts of specific engineering design parameters in the context of geologic uncertainty as a means to both understand and maximize profitability of the production operation. The MARS model is initially developed from a training dataset generated by a finite set of computationally complex hydrothermal models applied to the prospect. Its application reveals that the optimal engineering design variables can differ considerably assuming different choices of hydrothermal flow properties, which, in turn, indicates the importance of reducing the uncertainty of key geologic properties. The major uncertainty sources in the natural-system are identified and ranked first by an efficient MARS-enabled total order sensitivity quantification, which is then used to assist evaluating the effect of geological uncertainties on optimized results. At the Southern California prospect, this parameter sensitivity analysis suggests that groundwater circulation through high permeable structures, rather than heat conduction through impermeable granite, is the primary heat transfer method during geothermal extraction. Reservoir histories simulated using optimal parameters with different constraints are analyzed and compared to investigate the longevity and maximum profit of the geothermal resources. The comparison shows that the longevity and profit are very likely to be overestimated by optimizations without appropriate constraints on natural conditions. In addition to geothermal energy production, this optimization approach can also be used to manage other geologic resource operations, such as hydrocarbon production or CO2 sequestration, under uncertain reservoir conditions.

KW - Geothermal

KW - Optimization

KW - Sensitivity

KW - Surrogate

KW - Uncertainty

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84908691415&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84908691415&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.10.036

DO - 10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.10.036

M3 - Article

VL - 137

SP - 352

EP - 363

JO - Applied Energy

JF - Applied Energy

SN - 0306-2619

ER -